The values set to the items in the Items collection of RadComboBox need to be unique for every item for this is the value which identifies an item. Setting the same value to more than one item will result in inconsistent selection of the items.
I hope the information provided will be helpful to explain the weird behavior with RadComboBox selection.
the Telerik team
If you want to get updates on new releases, tips and tricks and sneak peeks at our product labs directly from the developers working on the RadControls for ASP.NET AJAX, subscribe to their blog feed